Mini-Review: Joanna Shupe’s “TYCOON”

TycoonJoanna Shupe’s “Tycoon,” the introductory novella to her Gilded-Age-set Knickerbocker Club series, opens with one of the funniest scenes Miss Bates has read in ages! At NYC’s Grand Central Depot, eponymous tycoon, Theodore “Ted” Harper waits for his private Pullman car. In a blink, a feisty young woman accosts him:  

Ted Harper never saw it coming. Once minute, he was alone on the platform, and the next he’d acquired a wife.

“There you are, dear husband! Let’s not miss the train,” said a loud, husky feminine voice.

What in the name of Jacob? He tried to extricate his arm from her unexpectedly strong grip while glancing around for a porter. A patrolman. A crowbar … Anyone or anything to dislodge this woman from his side …

“I’m looking forward to meeting your mother,” she said and began propelling him toward the train. “I do hope she can teach me to cook that apple pie you like so much.” Mother? Ted frowned. His mother had been dead for eight years. Crazy, thy name is woman …

Ted’s staid, solitary life, dedicated to growing his New American Bank, will never be the same. Miss Clara Dobson, Hoyt’s department store perfume-seller, takes him in firm hand and makes great use of his stupefaction and bemusement to escape from the dangerous men who are following her. 

Shupe’s Clara is a great spirit while her Ted is dispirited. At 32, Ted’s whole life has been to grow his fortune, from humble beginnings as Ohio farm boy to his present millionaire banker status. And yet, he’s never experienced an emotionally intimate relationship. He’s had women, but never one who brings out his exasperation, protectiveness, and roaring lust as Clara does. Clara is irrepressibly plucky. She left her own humble Missouri farm-family to lead an independent life in New York City. She made a great go of it: achieving star-perfume-seller success and holding her in a huge city … until she witnessed a crime and found herself on the run from bad guys. Ted’s heart comes awake around Clara: she fascinates him, irritates him adorably, challenges his notions of womanhood, and makes him question his single status. Clara herself is of an open-hearted, generous, and affectionate disposition. She likes Ted’s quiet ways, sky-blue eyes, broad shoulders, and ability to deal with challenges with shrewdness, . She likes his kisses and she easily falls in love with him. They fight the bad guys on board train and Ted fights his attraction and the stirrings of his heart.

Miss Bates enjoyed many of “Tycoon”‘s elements. She loved that it was set on a late-19-century train of velvet seats, luxurious, genteel dining, and sleeping cars. Ted and Clara were most likeable. Shupe’s writing was at times fun and funny, at others, quite elegant. But Miss Bates has never been a novella-fan and “Tycoon” suffers from underdevelopment. Miss Bates never understood what made Ted so averse to emotional engagement and attachment. The villains were caricaturish and the mystery flatly resolved. Ted exhibited some annoyingly typical “women are not to be trusted” attitudes, but spunky Clara set him straight. Though Ted’s attitude was vexing, Miss Bates loved how Clara demanded his trust, not just his love and fidelity, and how she stood her ground on retaining her independence. A romance novella is always a mere taste of a delicious dish, which is why Miss Bates is going to read the rest of the Knickerbocker Club romance novels. 😉 With her reading sidekick, Miss Austen, Miss Bates deems “Tycoon,” to be a “real comfort,” Emma.

Joanna Shupe’s “Tycoon” is published by Zebra Books (Kensington Publishing). It was released on February 23rd and may be found at your preferred vendors. Miss Bates received an e-ARC from Zebra/Kensington, via Netgalley.

11 thoughts on “Mini-Review: Joanna Shupe’s “TYCOON”

  1. I’m not a novella fan, either, for the same reasons you stated, but I can’t resist the timeframe of this one. MAGNATE is coming with me on vacation next week along with the 300 or so on my Kindle, (but who’s counting, right???), and there’s plenty of room for TYCOON. Just in case I get bored or begin to suffer withdrawal symptoms from lack of reading material, you know. 😉


    1. Yup, novella just annoy me, especially when they’re held out to reel in readers for the big stuff that’s coming. BUT that opening scene may be worth it! I have MAGNATE too to read soon … ish. B/c like you, massive TBR. You’re going on holiday! Have a wonderful time and happy reading, of course!


  2. I’ve never read Joanna Shupe-the plot summaries of her Regency novels were not to my taste, and seemed ridiculous and implausible. But this one is pushing all the right buttons.


    1. I agree: the Regency plots were ho-hum/nope for me, but this setting and humour, despite the disappointing second half, bodes really well for the series!


  3. I downloaded the sample, but at the price, I will probably buy. I like the premise and am less unhappy with the novella length than you are. I may conclude the resolution is rushed or the villains cardboard, but since I often spend the 25-60% mark of a romance wondering where the plot is going (or whether there is one) or stuck on a conflict I don’t want to read more of, the shorter length might be a relief for me.


    1. That’s the best reasoning I’ve read today! The writing stays good throughout. I’m looking forward to the other books: I like her feminist heroine and I like the historical setting a lot! Opening scene is priceless!


Comments are closed.