REVIEW: Caroline Linden’s AN EARL LIKE YOU

An_Earl_Like_YouReaders familiar with MBRR will know I am interested in romance’s dark moment, which I define as a betrayal. The darker and more heinous the betrayal, the better executed the narrative tension, when it seems as if hero and heroine will never mend their rift. In Linden’s latest, An Earl Like You (second in the series The Wagers of Sin), this new-to-me author deftly creates a romance which sustains the coming betrayal from the first chapter to the final. I was coiled with tension from the get-go which I attribute to Linden’s premise. Upon his father’s death, Hugh Deveraux, 7th Earl of Hastings, learns that the 6th earl’s profligate ways left their family destitute: estates given to gardens and follies rather than tenants, debts galore, two sisters dowry-less and a mother grieving; the Deveraux women are ignorant of their new circumstances … and Hugh wants to keep it that way. What’s a peer to do but take to the gambling tables in a desperate attempt to ensure his mother’s well-being and sisters’ future? Until Hugh loses and is faced with a devil’s bargain from a wealthy speculator, Edward Cross, looking to ensure his daughter’s future. Cross asks Hugh to meet him at his palatial Greenwich home, tells him he now holds his debts and will call them in …  unless Hugh woos and wins Cross’s plain, spinster daughter, Eliza. 

Reading the raw premise, you’d think Hugh mercenary, Edward manipulative, and Eliza gullible. But Linden managed to give them a nuance and sympathy that surprised and delighted me. Edward, though less developped, is a man who loves his daughter, feels the ache of her motherlessness, and carefully chooses and crafts a marriage that proves compatible in body, spirit, and mind. Hugh is a man who has come to realize his father’s charm and joie de vivre covered his carelessness, ” … his father’s good nature had concealed a few intractable flaws.” Hugh is grim and serious, bent on gambling his way to estate solvency and caring for his mother and sisters.

Hugh is everything steady, sure, secure, and loving to his family. When confronted with Edward’s ultimatum, though he’d sacrifice himself for his family, he also wants to behave in a caring and honourable manner towards Eliza. And is Eliza a naïve dufus? I loved Eliza. She was smart, caring, funny, and loving. There is no doubt that Hugh and Eliza are compatible and their marriage can be a long and happy one. But there stands that devil’s bargain between them: Hugh’s secret and Eliza’s unworldly love. 

I adored Eliza’s capacity for happiness. We are introduced to her at her father’s Greenwich house, which she has made beautiful and comfortable. She lives contentedly with her beloved dog, the irrepressible foundling mutt, Willy, and her gardening. Our Eliza has the great makings of a feral, happy spinster. She ponders her fate: “Eliza was coming to accept, deep down, that she would end up as one of those rich old ladies with a pack of dogs – she hoped to be quite an eccentric – ” Her father, on the other hand, is insistent on marriage and family. But Eliza’s sole “Season” left her a traumatized wallflower, uninterested in her suitors, their suits obvious plays for her fortune. Eliza is no fool.

Eliza possesses a delightful humour. She says to her father, “Eliza folded her hands and assumed a dreamy expression. ‘Surely there’s some viscount or baronet out there, titled and handsome but dull-witted and utterly penniless, who might be willing to have me?’ ” What Eliza says is sad, but what she does, her gesture and expression, speak of her wit and humour. And she is happy: ” ‘Even as a spinster. If I never meet a handsome, charming, dull-witted, impoverished baronet, I shall still be happy, with you and Willy and my friends.” And her garden. I believed her. When the handsome earl shows up, however, well-mannered and warm, she falls in love. 

Hugh, on the other hand, has Edward’s ultimatum hanging over him like a Damocles sword. I liked how Linden painted Hugh’s sensitivity and sensibility. Hugh isn’t a lady-player and he gambles only because he can win the money necessary to keep up an appearance of wealth for his mother and sisters. He doesn’t want to lie, but feels compelled to do so to protect those he loves. While he isn’t in love with Eliza YET, he likes her and immediately recognizes her qualities:

She wasn’t a beauty, nor even very pretty. London society would call her plain. But when she gazed at a man that way, with her heart in her eyes, she was not ordinary.

… she was as he had thought the first time he met her, somewhat shy but kind and decent.

She was warm, generous, and honest, with a quiet but droll sense of humor, and he found himself looking forward to seeing her.

What was wrong with him? She’d made him laugh, of course, saying she’d never been well kissed. A charming joke from a spinster. So he’d kissed her again, and somehow between the sensual little moans she made and the way her fingers dug into his shirt as if she wanted to tear it off, he’d gone a bit mad.

Eliza was … well, aside from her parentage, she was lovely. Genuine, warm, and kind … Eliza was exactly as she appeared to be. But deep down, Hugh knew it was very bad that she didn’t know. That made him a liar, a cheat, and a manipulator, just as bad as her father. The more he knew Eliza, the more he liked her.

Eliza … All she did was think of others and give freely of herself and her time … giving Hugh her heart when he didn’t deserve it.

Linden did a marvelous job of giving us the trajectory of Hugh’s slow-burn love for Eliza. What begins as a recognition of her qualities moves to esteem. As esteem grows, Hugh’s attraction burns. As liking blooms, Hugh seeks Eliza’s companionship, advice, and conversation. And as Hugh’s feelings strengthen, so does his guilt at deceiving his wife and fear of hurting her and losing her.

Eliza and Hugh are people who thrive in marriage and family life. They celebrate fidelity and commitment. They don’t adhere to vows out of duty and responsibility only. They enjoy each other, in bed and out. They’re mature, loving, and flourish within a comfortable, quiet family home. They’re the best of home-makers, really. And their capacity for happiness in their compatibility is bittersweet: the reader knows that Hugh’s attempt to protect his beloved wife from the truth (and he truly struggles with this, telling or not telling her) will come home to roost in the worst possible way. Their confrontation is magnificent and their reconciliation heart-clenchingly good. Linden is given to exposition, but the characters and story were so good, I overlooked it. With Miss Austen, here’s what we say about one of the best romances I’ve read this year, “there is no charm equal to tenderness of heart,” Emma.

Caroline Linden’s An Earl Like You is published by Avon Books. It released on August 28th and may be procured from your preferred vendor. I received an e-ARC from Avon Books, via Edelweiss+.

14 thoughts on “REVIEW: Caroline Linden’s AN EARL LIKE YOU

  1. I am a fan of Caroline Linden, and really looking forward to this one-one of my favorite tropes! She does great wallflower books. You pretty much can’t go wrong with any of her older works. I have not yet caught up with some of the newer ones.


    1. This was my first, but won’t be my last. The two leads were sigh-worthy wonderful, three-dimensional and yet so sympathetic and likeable, with realistic responses to circumstances and each other. You’ll love it!


  2. Good to hear this. I’ve seen this at the book store but I’m just, er, a lot more reticent to add to TBR these days. Part of it is the “once-bitten, twice/thrice shy” nervousness and part of it is just sheer stubbornness not to feed the monster that is my TBR. I’m making every effort to reduce the Mount TBR to at least a hill or maybe a smallish sand dune. Something that doesn’t make me shudder and hide behind my hands.

    I’ve read and enjoyed many of Ms. Linden’s historicals. I think I began with A Rake’s Guide To Seduction which I enjoyed a lot. Enough that for a while I bought/preordered everything she wrote. Sadly, I think I somehow allowed her to slip through the cracks for the past several years, and now, as I said, I’m just a wee bit more cautious about plunking down my $$ for a book. Thanks for the review.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. You’re welcome! That is the way of TBRs, isn’t it???!!! I’m pretty self-indulgent about books I admit. I just love them so. They represent PROMISE and RESPITE.

      BTW, I’m reading Cassandra By Chance for the order of pub great Betty read. Love it so far!


      1. That’s the problem with my TBR. Indulgence. I let it take over an entire room. Now the TBR bookcase groans warningly, I’ve run out of plastic bins to store the overflow (and space tbh), and I’m not really sure what I have or why I bought certain ones. Honestly, my TBR has taken on all the characteristics of The Blob. Ibdescribable, indestructible, and nothing can stop it!

        Ah Cassandra By Chance. Shades of Jane Eyre in that one. And best line to describe Cassandra’s mass confusion/dogged determination to pair Benedict off with someone else summed up best by Benedict: “a worse case of putting two and two together and making five I have yet to meet…” A really good Betty book. I’m up to The Fifth Day of Christmas but was hijacked by Duran’s Bound By Your Touch and Rick Bragg’s The Best Cook In The World.


        1. You know your TBR is bad when you are almost happy to DNF a book, because now you’ve crossed it off the list with minimal effort. I just DNF’d two this weekend, with almost no guilt!

          Liked by 1 person

          1. 😂 Yes! I have guilt-free DNFed so many, I’m almost giddy. At least I’m beginning to see what I have and UBS gave me a healthy credit this weekend for those discards. But oh the horror! What was I thinking when I bought some of these!?!?

            Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes, if The Shrew were a romance. Instead, a true humble hero, lovely heroine, even the scheming father is somewhat redeemed. He was, after all, motivated by love, not expediency. A truly lovely read.


  3. I just finished this quite late last night. So lovely. I just wasn’t expecting how lovely they would be together and with each other. For the duration. Bravo. And now I want to go back and read Sophie’s book.


  4. It sounds intriguing though I really struggle with heroes who lie to “protect” their womenfolk. Is this ever addressed, regarding Hugh’s mother and sisters?


    1. It is and I can say that it makes sense in terms of their aristocratic status and Hugh’s inflated sense of obligation and responsibility. Also, histrom makes it more understandable, believable? Everyone is just so nice, so nuanced, that it all just worked for me!

      Liked by 1 person

Comments are closed.