Review: Allison Montclair’s THE UNKEPT WOMAN (Sparks and Bainbridge Mystery #4)

Unkept_Woman…and possibly my favourite of the series (#1 is marvellous too). Montclair takes the narrative threads set up in book one, The Right Sort of Man, and brings them to some resolution. In The Unkept Woman, Iris Sparks finally reckons with her past and Gwen Bainbridge gains in strength and resolve, which go a long way to bring her closer to regaining custody of her finances and son (as we learn from book one, Gwen had what would be deemed in post-war England a “nervous breakdown” and was declared “incompetent” [legal term] losing custody of her son, Ronnie, and finances, given over to her conservative, draconian in-laws. Gwen’s emotional collapse came at the death of her husband, Ronald Bainbridge, in WWII). But in the latest volume, Sparks’ past returns: she is the eponymous “unkept woman”, having broken off from the married man she’d been having an affair with, on and off, during and post war-time intelligence training and action. But things are more complicated than what I’ve described so far.

The latest volume opens with a visit from Polish emigrée Helena Jablonska seeking Iris and Gwen’s Right Sort Marriage Bureau matchmaking services. Two days later, Helena is found shot dead in Iris’s apartment and Gwen and Iris are back on the sleuthing path, accompanied by their partner-in-sleuthing, Salvatore Danielli, “Sally” to his friends, a giant playwright who, like Iris, played a role in war-time intelligence; add the “usual suspects” to the mix: the hilarious, loveable servants of Gwen’s household, really her in-laws’ household but their hearts lie with Gwen, Iris, and the irrepressible Ronnie; Iris’s occasional amour, “spiv” Archie Spelling; a new assortment of post-war Polish emigrés embittered by Yalta, mysterious MI6 figures, and the return of Detective Mike Kinsey of Scotland Yard, Iris’s the one-who-got-away. Truly a marvellous assortment.

The series’ strengths are many: in this case, even better pacing, which kept me glued, seamlessly integrated historical detail, a wonderful combination of consistent, unifying narrative threads with a unique storyline in the murder and its resolution, great “banterish” dialogue, and, of course, the emotionally-engaging characters.

Most of all, to put it simply, I adore Gwen and Iris because they are simultaneously vulnerable and strong. And they share that most precious of relationships, a friendship; even more than the historical detail, intrepid adventures, and love interests, the Sparks and Bainbridge mystery series is about a wonderful partnership and friendship between two woman. And it isn’t the sappy WF kind: it’s playful, fun, and banter-filled, but no less supportive and deeply-felt. A passage encompassing these qualities is the conversation between Gwen and Iris as Iris confesses to Gwen the latest mess she’s landed in thanks to the return of her married lover and his possible connection to the mysterious Helena, RIP: 

“Keep going. Tell me I’m a failure and a coward and that I deserve to live a lonely life and die alone and be found half eaten by an excessive number of cats who only pretended to love me because I fed them.”

“Wait, I need to write all that down,” said Gwen as Iris threw herself facedown on her bed. “What have you failed at?”

“Everything,” said Iris.

“Move over,” said Gwen, climbing onto the bed next to her. “What brought this on?”

“Your mother-in-law’s whiskey.”

“And what brought that on?”

“Your mother-in-law.”

The entire novel is suffused with this combination of pathos and wit. Witness the following passage where Iris expresses how fed up she is with her spying war-work interfering with her present life:

“All I want is to bring lonely people together for the lifetime of love that has been denied me. I don’t want death and subterfuge dogging my footsteps everywhere I go. I want to show up at the office at nine o’clock Monday morning and find that Gwen has beaten me there yet again to regale me with Little Ronnie’s latest. And when the workday is done, I want to go back to my own flat and curl up with a good book or a bad man.”

Other than to “regale” you with how well-written and fun the dialogue is, this passage also illustrates one of the themes I most appreciate about the series: how Gwen and Iris, representative of the war-wounded (it’s not only combat veterans war injures) work to regain a sense of normality, of a life no longer lived on an emotional “edge”. Montclair brings this theme home in a “show-not-tell” way by having, throughout the four volumes (digits crossed there will be more), Gwen’s and Iris’s sessions with a therapist, Dr. Milford, a sympathetic, perspicacious figure and cause for more terrifically-rendered dialogue.

In sum, if you haven’t read the series, go to book one and start now; if you have, don’t miss out on the latest (releasing today). In Miss Austen’s more eloquent words, The Unkept Woman is proof “there is no charm equal to tenderness of heart,” Emma.

I am grateful to Minotaur Books for an opportunity to read and review an e-galley of The Unkept Woman, offered via Netgalley.

17 thoughts on “Review: Allison Montclair’s THE UNKEPT WOMAN (Sparks and Bainbridge Mystery #4)

  1. Lovely, lovely review! I agree, it is the marvelous friendship between Gwen and Iris that makes this a winning series. I love them both.
    Grrr, my library still shows this as ‘on order’. I wants it now, my preciousss.

    Liked by 1 person

      1. I finally got the book at 4:30 pm yesterday and finished it at 1 am this morning. There was a 3 hour break in there where Real Life intruded, but I was otherwise glued to the book. I loved it! I agree, this is the best so far. My favorite scene was Gwen trying to explain things to Rawlins Stronach, the lawyer she was hiring to represent her in court re: her sanity hearing. That early scene was both a glimpse of Gwen’s current state of mind and a very clever way for the author to recap the first three books.
        Now begins waiting for the next book. Sigh…


        1. As usual, we are in total agreement! I’m so glad you enjoyed it. It really is the best of them, with the début, a close rival. I can’t wait for the next one, so I’m trying not to think about it.

          Am reading the latest Wrexford and Sloane in anticipation of the new one come the end of September and *just* got the latest, Ruth Galloway #14, in the mail. Alas, it looks like Ruth #15 will be the series’ final book…and there better be an HEA!


            1. Ah, Mike, Mike, Mike…more “good” heartbreak may come your way. How much do you love Gwen???!!! And Ronnie!!!!??? Have you met the narwhal? Iris is prickly, but you’ll love her too. I’m so glad you’re enjoying it, you deserve a good read!

              Liked by 1 person

            2. I read it through (who needs sleep?) and had to force myself not to start on the second and keep going.

              Heartbreak: yes, this is not a romance series, but oh man. OH MAN.

              And I love them all. Iris breaks my heart because she’s so broken (and of course one wonders what ELSE happened during the war years). Gwen breaks my heart because she’s so strong despite all the losses, and despite her not being sure she is that strong. Ronnie is fantastic (a child who is a child not a plot moppet, hooray!). And Sally. And Mike. And Des (oh, Des) and… ::sigh::

              Liked by 1 person

            3. Oh my dear, you are HOOKED!!! I can’t wait to hear what you make of book#4 b/c it’s all Iris all the time, except for Gwen’s courage and friendship, which is key always to, that is, friendship, to what is best about the series. Hope you keep enjoying them and a book hangover is the best hangover: all of the cachet, none of the detriment… 😉

              Liked by 1 person

  2. Oh, I do love them all, Sally and Mike and Archie, and of course Iris and Gwen. I am also on the library wait list!


Leave a comment for Miss Bates ....

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s