REVIEW: Lauren Willig’s THE SUMMER COUNTRY

Summer_CountryLauren Willig’s “summer country” is early nineteenth and Victorian-Era-set Barbados. A young women arrives in Bridgetown in February 1854, Miss Emily Dawson, to claim her inheritance, the ruined sugar-producing estate of Peverills, only to discover a family history that alters everything she has known about who she is.

Since the *sniff* end to the Pink Carnation series and we can see vestiges of this theme there too, Willig’s novels centre around a heroine’s journey of unearthing familial and historical identity. Willig’s specializes in, to nay-say the Bard’s Hamlet, a “discovered country” that alters and then cements a new future for our heroine. The Summer Country‘s Emily Dawson is such a heroine, as she delves into the Barbadian history of slavery, white privilege and exploitation of others, and the personal tragedies and triumphs of parallel stories, one set in 1812-1816, and the heroine’s present, 1854, the 1812-16 narrative bearing on Emily’s present and future.

With this in mind and from the perspective of a reader who’s read to the final page, Willig’s early line rings ironic, “Emily wanted to see it all.” As an adventuresome, poor, unassuming spinster character who’s divested of looks and flirtation, Emily can freely take in the atmosphere, characters, history, and landscape of Barbados when she arrives with cousin Adam and best friend, Laura, also Adam’s wife. Adam has inherited their grandfather’s interests and company, while Emily has to decide what to do with Perverills, the legacy her usually business-savvy, tight-fisted grandfather left to her. Will she sell? Most likely, but she wants to explore what led her grandfather to purchase it and, moreover, leave it to her.

The British-borne-and-bred Adam, Laura, and Emily arrive on Barbados’s shores as European ingenues and are soon embroiled in the convoluted relationships of the island’s wealthy whites, newly freed, prosperous former slaves, and its “redlegs,” poor whites once hailing from Ireland and Scotland. Her grandfather, Jonathan Fenty, was one such. As Emily takes in the heat, sounds, strangeness and vibrancy of Barbados, she is brought into the fold of one wealthy sugar estate owner, Mrs. Davenant, and her grandson, George. Emily is also introduced to a wealthy, accomplished former slave family, the Turners, and their aloof nephew, Dr. Nathaniel Braithwaite. In one of the opening chapters, Nathaniel escorts Emily as far as Peverills’s adjoining estate, Beckles, where Mrs. Davenant reigns supreme and keeps nephew George under her mighty thumb.

When Nathaniel refuses to enter Beckles, Emily realizes that the social strata and relations between former owners and present freemen and women are still tense with an exploitative, violent, humiliating history. We are then introduced to the second narrative, set in the early nineteenth century, when Peverills was a financially-strapped but unscathed estate, and its abolitionist dreamer owner, Charles Davenant. Charles abandoned Barbados and his ownership of Peverills (eventually selling to Jonathan Fenty, Emily’s grandfather) after the slave uprising of 1816, when the estate was burned to the ground.

As Emily reviews estate records and speaks with people who knew her grandfather in his young, upcoming, Barbadian years, we alternately follow the story of Charles Davenant of 1812 (like Emily years later, newly arrived to Barbados from England to take over Perverills) and the adjoining estate’s mistress’s, Mary Anne Beckles, personal slave, Jenny. Of all the novel’s characters, Jenny looms the largest and most interesting. She is the heart of the tragedy of slavery and also symbolic of the possibility of happiness and freedom. Jenny is clever, strong, and adept at surviving amongst the whims and machinations of the petty, avaricious, exploitative people who surround her. Mary Anne Beckles is dark to Jenny’s light: cruelly capricious and selfish, she is attached to Jenny as her “property.” Mary Anne’s not physically cruel, but she views Jenny as born to cater to her, to lavish her with attention and see to her every need, from fanning during the heat to fetching and drawing and keeping her company. One of my favourite parts takes place when Emily sees a portrait of Mary Anne, with a vague figure hovering behind her, seemingly subservient, but the figure with the greatest story to tell and the greatest triumph over adversity — Jenny.

Emily’s journey is one where she uncovers how figures like Jenny, Charles, even Mary Anne, the past, is a place of subterfuge and secrets. Again, a theme linking Willig’s novels, including, albeit in a comic mode, the Pink Carnation series. In The Summer Country, Willig’s canvas is large: the historical struggles to defeat the injustice of slavery, of the sin of treating the other as property, as well as the personal journey, as entangled with history, of a young woman discovering an identity and its possibilities in a new world with a new sense of who she is. I think because Willig’s canvas was writ large, I had to be patient to follow what was a lengthy set-up to her stories. In time, however, I was rewarded with slowly, surely, and fascinatingly converging narrative lines. Willig is a master of narrative convergence through dawning revelations. Happily, the revelations, when they arrive, show her still-committed to the romance HEA. Willig’s Summer Country is a wonderful novel. With Miss Austen, we find within it “a mind lively and at ease,” Emma

Lauren Willig’s The Summer Country is published by William Morrow. It was released on June 4th and may be found at your preferred vendor. I received an e-galley from William Morrow, via Edelweiss+.

8 thoughts on “REVIEW: Lauren Willig’s THE SUMMER COUNTRY

  1. I really enjoyed this, as I love a book that demands that I Pay Attention to everything the writer presents to me.
    Please tell me that you pictured Bette Davis as Mary Ann. I actually dinged the book a half-star over at GR because I thought the characterization was just too obvious. (I thought ‘Jezebel’ for the younger Mary Ann and ‘Hush, Hush Sweet Charlotte’ for the older Mrs Davenant)
    I found the author’s historical notes just as fascinating as the book itself.
    Of course, I loved the very last chapter, where all of the ‘oh my’ lightbulbs go off. Emily and Nathaniel are going to have a very interesting and emotional honeymoon trip to Paris, niest-ce pas?

    Like

    • I actually didn’t think of Bets Davis, but now that you’ve put those images in my head, she will be FOREVER thus! LOL!

      I devoured the historical notes as well, knowing next to nothing about Barbados … and its history. Now, I’m going to cast Charles as Mel Ferrer in War and Peace, what say you?

      I thought the final chapters were PERFECTION, LOVED THEM. Such a commitment to the HEA Willig still has, thank you! Much better than The English Wife, though I loved the book. I loved the Shakespeare woven through and it may be a better book than this one. This, I thought, was definitely histfic. t’other more of a hybrid.

      Paris will be WOW!

      Like

      • Hmmm, Mel Ferrar (Prince Andre in W&P)–I never really put a face on Charles but Mel’s would be a good one.
        Though the main couple in ‘The English Wife’ was doomed, I thought she left Janie and the reporter on the cusp of a romance, with the possibility of a good outcome. I do hope she finds a way to work them into another book.
        I did chortle at Willig’s description of ‘Summer Country’ as a cross between an MM Kaye book and ‘Thorn Birds’. I knew exactly which MM Kaye book she meant. Emily is much nicer than Hero Hollis from ‘Trade Wind’. Much Nicer.

        Like

        • I agree about Janie and I’d love to see her the journo sleuthing in another book. Yes!! I’ve only read one MMKaye book and it was The Far Pavilions, but I totally get what she meant by the vibe. And The Thorn Birds, lordie, that was the read back in the day, wasn’t it? She makes a few caustic little comments about novel-reading along the way and I loved it.

          Like

  2. Beautiful review. I’m looking forward to reading this one (but I have to whittle my TBR down a bit first – the good/bad thing of doing a cleanup and inventory of the bookshelves is finding books that I don’t even remember buying).

    Like

Leave a comment for Miss Bates ....

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s